Welcome to TheConsumersReports. Please note that we are not affiliated, associated, authorized, endorsed by, or in any way officially connected with the Consumer Reports, Inc., or any of its subsidiaries or its affiliates or its websites. Consumer Reports website can be found at https://www.consumerreports.org

Best Ice Cream Maker Consumer Reports – Reviews Of 10 Top Picks

Do you want to get over with tasteless and expensive ice creams sold in the supermarket, and create your own ice creams, sorbets, and frozen yogurts at home? Your idea is good, but you still need to know which ice cream maker to choose according to your expectations and requirements. There are many different types of ice cream makers doing the rounds in the market, and if you decide without putting in enough thoughts, you may probably end up buying a wrong machine.

We have therefore decided to help you in your choice by presenting 10 best ice cream maker consumer reports with a detailed review of each of those 10 products. The motive is simple, helping you identify the best ice cream maker for your money and requirements.

Reviews Of 10 Best Ice Cream Makers


Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence Ice Cream Maker

Want to invest in an ice cream maker? Well, check out this incredible model by Cuisinart, which doesn’t just prepare ice creams, but frozen yogurt too. Boasting a stylish and durable design, you can prepare your favorite ice creams for years without worrying about the machine’s health. As far as preparing ice cream is concerned, then you just need to add the ingredients, turn the machine on and wait for 25 minutes to get the raw materials turned into the sweet, frozen delight you’ve been craving for.

The ice cream maker boasts a powerful motor, which helps you prepare up to 2-quart ice cream every day. The company has used BPA-free plastic in the product, which is 100% safe for human consumption. The company offers a 3-year warranty on the product against all manufacturing defects, so in case anything happens, you can get it repaired or replaced by the company.

back to menu ↑

COSTWAY Commercial Ice Cream Machine

If you are looking to buy an ice cream machine for your ice cream parlor, then COSTWAY brings to you the best commercial ice cream machine available on the market right now. It is widely used in dessert shops, cafes, bars, milk-tea stores, hotels, fruit juice bars, and many other commercial outlets. It can be used to prepare 4 different shapes of ice creams with the same consistency. It features 2 modes and 5 choices, which allow you to choose the ice cream of your choice. Using this machine is a breeze, thanks to its LED display, which lets you control the temperature, hardness, and quantity of the ice cream.

You can easily add your favorite ingredients such as chocolate chips, berries, nuts, or meringue during the mixing process. The ice cream machine comes with a 2.6-liter capacity, which can easily meet your daily ice cream requirements. When you are done preparing your favorite ice cream, just pour water into the hopper and press the ‘Clean’ button. It will take 3-5 minutes for the machine to clean itself. Once that happens, press down the handle to let the water out of the hopper.

back to menu ↑

Nostalgia ICMW400 4 Quart Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker

This ice cream maker from Nostalgia is a beautiful looking product, which will remind you of ice cream makers of the past. The machine comes with a powerful electric motor, which is responsible for preparing the ice cream. The company has added a 4-quart aluminum canister in the ice cream maker, which is encased in a wooden bucket to let you enjoy the original taste of hand-made ice cream.

As far as operating this ice cream maker is concerned, then that is quite simple and so as the cleaning. The machine is also available in the 6-quart model, so in case, you want a bigger machine, then you can choose the 6-quart model. You will also get an instruction manual along with a recipe book with the machine to help you prepare unique dishes with ease.

back to menu ↑

Lello Musso Pola 5030 Dessert Maker

If you want to make 1 or 2-Quart batch of frozen desserts with commercial ice cream maker, then Lello Musso Pola will serve your purpose. You can prepare up to 6 quarts of frozen yogurts, sweet sorbets, fresh fruit, ice cream, and delicious gelato in a single go. Its outer body is made up of stainless steel that provides strength and classic finish.

The stainless steel is also used in the manufacturing of its blades that defines its efficiency and durability. This machine has a built-in freezing unit, so you don’t require any additional freezer, salt, or ice for keeping the ice-cream cool for longer.

back to menu ↑

Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Upright Stainless Steel Bowl Ice Cream Maker

Take a look at this amazing ice cream maker, which has been built from high-quality stainless steel. A right unit for individuals who want to prepare up to 2 liters of ice cream in one go. Just imagine yourself sitting in a room that has the best window air conditioner and your favorite couch. Would you not enjoy the ice cream you have just prepared while watching your favorite show or movie? Of course, you will.

The company has inducted the automatic motor inside it which gets off if the unit is longer in use. If you want to view the settings or see any other important information like time remaining to prepare a dessert, then an LCD controlled is affixed on the top. You can easily remove and clean the stainless steel bowl featured within. As far as the safety or health of a user is concerned, the company has used CFC-free refrigerant.

back to menu ↑

Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

If you are Frigophill and can go to any extent to satisfy your cravings, then Breville BC1600XL Smart Scoop maker is the product you should go for, which is no doubt the expensive one but will cater to your needs of preparing delicious frozen delights. This ice cream maker has a self-refrigerating compressor that can keep the ice cream below -5 degrees Celsius for up to 3 hours. You can prepare 1.5 quarts of ice cream with this product in just 30 minutes. This product consists of a motor, compressor, spatula, dasher, control panel, removable bowl, and cleaning brush.

There is an LCD control panel given on the top of this unit from where you can adjust the settings and set the timer manually. As a whole, the company has introduced all those features in this product, which are important from the user’s point of view and minimize the intervention. You have the option of selecting from 12 different hardness settings to prepare varied frozen items like Gelato, sorbet, and Yogurt. Coming to the drawback of this unit, it is a bit expensive and the ingredients start to freeze after an hour or two.

back to menu ↑

Dash DIC001AQ Deluxe Ice Cream Frozen Yogurt & Sorbet Maker

Do you want to include some organic, creamy sorbet, frozen yogurt or non-dairy ice cream in your meals, then invest in Dash deluxe ice cream maker. You just need to freeze the bowl overnight and on the next day, you can make mouth-watering creamy homemade ice cream in not more than 30 minutes. The ingredient spout makes it possible to add mix-ins to create a match made in heaven.

With a double-walled insulated freezer bowl, the ice cream can be kept frozen for hours, if you are planning to organize a party at home. Go creative with endless flavor options. This product is coming with 1 year of manufacturing warranty. Moreover, you will get access to the recipes database to learn to make different recipes.

back to menu ↑

Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart is among the innovator among different ice cream makers brands. The company is manufacturing these machines since the start. Cuisinart ICE-70 is one of the latest models of ice cream makers. You can make up to 2 quarts of ice cream in a single batch. You will find an LCD with easy to operate control panel featuring on the front. You can easily read the readings on the panel with the help of the LCD.

Multiple settings are available for gelato, ice cream, and sorbet to select from. The overall processing and paddle speed are quite impressive. You don’t need to worry about turning this ice cream maker off after some minutes or once the delicacies are prepared. There is an auto turn off feature along with the timer provided which you can configure as per your need.

Apart from this, a detachable cup is also added to measure add-ins and a whole given to put ingredients together inside. You will get a free recipe book with this ice cream maker. The only drawback noticed in this model is that the setup process is difficult for those who are trying for the first time.

back to menu ↑

Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

This model will remind you of traditional ice cream makers in which you simply need to add the Nostalgia ice cream mixes like Vanilla, Chocolate or strawberry into the Aluminum canister and add a layer of ice and salt. After churning it for 20-30 minutes, you can enjoy delicious ice cream at home. You can prepare up to 6 quarts of ice cream, gelato, or frozen yogurt in one batch with the Aluminum canister.

The powerful electric motor does the churning part, so you no need to do it manually. Its handles make it easy to carry product while the easy-clean bucket offers easy cleanup. You can view the ice cream flavor and freezer storage easily, courtesy to see-through lid provided on the top of this ice-cream maker. The company has provided the recipe book inside the packing to try delicious creation at home.

back to menu ↑

Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker

Enjoy ambrosial homemade and fully customize ice cream according to your taste with Whynter stainless steel Ice cream maker. In this easy to use the machine, you can prepare rich creamy gelato, sorbet, and ice cream from the comfort of your home. Boasting a large capacity, this ice cream lets you make up to two quarts of frozen dishes in a single batch.

Stainless steel glossy finish exterior with LCD touch panel control adds to the aesthetics to your kitchen corner. You don’t need to wait for hours for the mixture to pre-freeze in the mixing bowl as there is a built-in powerful compressor freezer for your convenience.

Summing Up

The best ice cream maker consumer reports can save you from the hassle of going to an ice cream parlor and waiting in queues to get your favorite ice creams. The price of an ice cream maker is definitely higher than the ice cream, but just think how many ice creams you can prepare with an ice cream maker. It is just a one-time investment and years of enjoyment afterward. Just select a product from the aforementioned list and go ahead with the purchase.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

The Consumers' Reports - Reviews Of Best Picks & Buying Guide